Compare And Contrast Essay: Jane Eyre vs. Amy Tan
Novel vs. Short Story
This paper discusses the novel Jane Eyre written by Charlotte Bronte and a short story “A Pair of Tickets” written by Amy Tan. Moreover, the paper compares and contrasts these two stories.
“A Pair of Tickets” is a short story written by Amy Tan that describes a journey of one Chinese-American lady who returns to China after the untimely death of her mother. “A Pair of Tickets” is a story with reference to a family and origins. June May is a Chinese woman who was born in the USA, but grew up within an American contextual society, but her mother grew up in China and later settled in America. In the story, almost all characters fit in her family (Tan 456). In addition, “A Pair of Tickets” is a story that grows naturally out of its setting. The writer of this book, Amy Tan, was born in California in 1951.
Jane Eyre is a novel by Charlotte Bronte that tells the story of a small, plain-faced, intellectual, and impassioned English orphan. Moreover, she was physically and emotionally neglected by her aunt and cousins, and afterward she joins a harsh humanity school (Bronte 364). Despite all that Jane went through, she remains strong and resolutely withstands the harsh world that oppresses her self-determination and even self-control.
When comparing the book Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte and “A Pair of Tickets” by Amy Tan, one can notice that, the main characters in both books are women, Jane Eyre and Amy Tan. In addition, the two stories describe the lives of the main heroines from childhood to adulthood. In “A Pair of Tickets”, Amy said that she was 15 and had vigorously denied that she had any Chinese whatsoever under her skin. Furthermore, the two characters suffer in their childhood, but later their life changes. For example, in Jane Eyre, the main heroine, Jane, is raised in a harsh home of her callous Aunt Reed. In order to get rid of the girl, the woman sends her to a rigid religious boarding school (Zach 345). On the other hand, in “A Pair of Tickets”, June suffers from the problem that she has an identity of a Chinese female. She struggles for thirty years and later accepts.
Jane Eyre is the story of love and passion, since Jane is extremely passionate and dedicated to a close personal relationship with God. Moreover, she falls in love with Mr. Rochester. The story of “A Pair of Tickets” by Amy Tan is a story of self-discovery. June May suffers for being a Chinese, and later after meeting her twin sister she accepts and resolves to joy. Furthermore, in the story of “A Pair of Tickets”, all characters are from June May family, June’s parents and her twin sister (Charlotte 245). Nevertheless, in the story by Charlotte Bronte, there are different characters from different families.
In the story of Amy Tan, there is a great use of camera. When June’s father meets with her aunt, she snaps a picture. She also takes a picture of her together with her twin sister that allows her to view the similarity (Bronte 323). In the story of Jane, she goes to a boarding school where she works hard despite all the harsh circumstances she undergoes.
In conclusion, the two girls struggle to get inner peace. Jane struggles to get home, and she believes to have it when she attends the boarding school, but this does not happen until she gets an ideal mate. In “A Pair of Tickets”, June struggles with the problem of having a Chinese blood on her until she meets her twin sister.